Hyperpartisanship Shouldn’t Trump the Bill of Rights
By Jason Pye | Due Process Institute | Vice President
This era of hyperpartisanship has brought out the worst in American politics. People who once insisted on reading the Constitution’s plain text now find room for exceptions when their side holds power. The colonists understood what happens when the people who wield power get to decide what protections everyone else can count on. The Declaration of Independence made this observation about human liberty that reached well beyond the colonies’ break with a distant king: among the abuses that justified independence were the denial of jury trials and the king’s power over whether judges kept their jobs and what they were paid.
Here we are, 250 years later, and we’re facing arguments that sharply conflict with the founding vision of due process. Worse, some Members of Congress, including some who once described themselves as “constitutionalists,” are on the wrong side of the argument. As someone whose journey in the policy world comes from a libertarian viewpoint, I’ve found it depressing to witness.
The Fifth Amendment requires the federal government to afford due process before depriving “any person” of life, liberty, or property. The Fourteenth Amendment imposes that obligation on the states as well. Due process means that the government must follow fair procedures before it seeks to take away a person’s life, liberty, or property. In practice, that generally means–at a minimum–that a person is given adequate notice of what the government intends to do and is given a meaningful chance to state their position to an impartial decisionmaker. In our American system of government, legislatures write laws, the executive enforces them, and courts decide individual cases. Each branch has a job to do before the government can take away someone’s rights, no matter who that person is. If the Founding Generation hadn’t meant that this applies to any and all persons, they would have said so.
Specifically, Alexander Hamilton counted arbitrary imprisonment among the “favorite and most formidable instruments of tyranny.” In Federalist No. 84, he lauded the constitutionally protected writ of habeas corpus, which allows someone in custody to ask a court to examine the legal basis for holding them. Legal scholars Nathan Chapman and Michael McConnell trace a related idea in the original understanding of due process.
Stalin’s Great Terror showed what an authoritarian regime could do once it stripped away those safeguards. In 1937, a secret Soviet police order set regional quotas for repression. Three-person panels called troikas could sentence people to death or years in labor camps. They worked through hundreds of files in a sitting, behind closed doors, with the accused absent and without a defender. The people named in those files never got to explain anything or to defend themselves. History is filled with other examples from authoritarian or totalitarian regimes. You need not look far to find them.
The Declaration’s promise of human liberty gives us a standard for how our government should treat people–all people. The Constitution puts that principle into practice. It doesn’t matter who’s in the White House or which political party has power. The Constitution is the constant, or at least it’s meant to be. When the government seeks to take away someone’s liberty, it owes that person the process the Constitution guarantees, whoever they are and whatever the government says they’ve done. We take human liberty seriously when we insist on those protections for people we may never know and may have little reason to sympathize with. Their liberty is as much ours as theirs.